Most people comparing investment tracking apps are stuck on the same question: do I just want to see my portfolio, or do I want to measure it? Empower and Sharesight sit on opposite sides of that line, which is why they get compared so often despite being built for different jobs. Empower aggregates your bank, retirement, brokerage, and credit accounts into one free dashboard with automatic updates and a net worth focus. Sharesight connects to dozens of brokerages and funds, then does the hard math Empower does not attempt: true time-weighted and money-weighted returns, dividend tracking, currency effects, and tax documents you can hand to an accountant. The decision tension is real: Empower costs nothing and covers your entire financial life but treats investments somewhat superficially, while Sharesight charges a subscription and delivers granular portfolio analytics for investors with multiple accounts, currencies, or international holdings. This guide compares them side by side across cost, performance accuracy, asset coverage, tax reporting, and usability so you can decide which kind of tool your money actually needs.
Get smart everyday buys delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year

Investment Planner: A 365-Day Guide to Smart Investing and Portfolio Management
- ✔ Format: Dated 365-day physical planner
- ✔ Tracking Scope: Investment planning and portfolio management
- ✔ Asset Classes Covered: Stocks, bonds, real estate, and other investment types

Asset Management Record Notebook: A Simple Log Book for Tracking Assets, Liabilities, Investments, Income, and Net Worth
- ✔ Format: Notebook / Log Book
- ✔ Tracking Scope: Assets, liabilities, investments, income, and net worth
- ✔ Structure: Predefined sections, undated

My Investment Logbook
- ✔ Format: Physical logbook
- ✔ Tracking Scope: Investment and financial records
- ✔ Structure: Open, minimally structured
At a Glance
| Criteria | Empower (formerly Personal Capital) | Sharesight | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free (revenue from advisory upsell) | Free for 10 holdings; paid plans roughly $15–$30+/month | A |
| Performance analytics | Basic portfolio returns and allocation view | Deep: TWR, MWR, dividend and currency tracking, benchmarking | B |
| Asset and account coverage | Wide: banks, cards, loans, retirement, real estate, crypto via integration | Focused on investments: stocks, ETFs, funds, some crypto; bank accounts excluded | A |
| Tax reporting | None to speak of | Strong: tax reports for multiple jurisdictions, CGT reports | B |
| Automatic syncing | Excellent for most US institutions | Good for supported brokers; manual trades for others | A |
| Net worth and budgeting tools | Excellent — full financial dashboard | None — investments only | A |
| International support | Limited; US-centric | Excellent: 30+ exchanges, multi-currency | B |
| Ease of setup | Very easy — link accounts in minutes | Moderate — broker sync or CSV import takes effort | A |
Investment Planner: A 365-Day Guide to Smart Investing and Portfolio Management

This planner earns our top spot because it solves the problem that defeats most investors: inconsistency. Its 365-day framework transforms tracking from a monthly afterthought into a daily practice, and that cadence change is genuinely valuable. Investors who check in on their portfolio daily notice patterns — drift, concentration risk, emotional reactions to market swings — that monthly reviewers miss entirely.Compared with the My Investment Logbook, which records whatever you decide to write whenever you decide to write it, this planner imposes helpful discipline. The dated structure removes the blank-page problem, and that makes it the right choice for anyone who has abandoned tracking systems before. Its coverage is also broader than the Asset Management Record Notebook in one important way: it spans stocks, bonds, real estate, and other asset classes, giving multi-asset investors a single home for planning across their entire portfolio rather than logging transactions after the fact.The tradeoff is real, though. A dated format is unforgiving — miss a week and the empty pages become a visible record of your lapse, which some users find demotivating. It is also a planning tool first and a record second, so investors who want a permanent, long-term ledger of transactions will outgrow it within a year. For building the tracking habit itself, however, nothing else in this lineup comes close.
Pros:
- 365-day structure builds a genuine tracking habit rather than occasional record-keeping
- Covers multiple investment types including stocks, bonds, and real estate
- Combines planning and tracking in one place instead of separating them
- Dated pages remove decision fatigue about what and when to record
Cons:
- Dated format makes skipped days or weeks visibly obvious, which some find discouraging
- Annual cycle means buying a new planner each year for continuous tracking
- Heavier planning focus makes it less suited to pure transaction logging
Best for: Investors of any experience level who want to build a consistent daily or weekly tracking and planning habit across multiple asset classes
Not ideal for: Long-term record keepers who need a permanent transaction ledger, or anyone who knows they will not maintain a daily practice
Bottom line: This pick makes the most sense for investors who want tracking to become a habit, not a chore — its daily structure is the strongest behavior-design feature in this lineup.
“This pick makes the most sense for investors who want tracking to become a habit, not a chore — its daily structure is the strongest behavior-design feature in this lineup.”
Asset Management Record Notebook: A Simple Log Book for Tracking Assets, Liabilities, Investments, Income, and Net Worth

Where the Investment Planner focuses on your portfolio, this notebook zooms out to your entire financial picture. It is the only option in this lineup that tracks liabilities alongside assets, which means it can actually compute your net worth over time — a metric that matters more to long-term wealth building than any single position’s performance. If your investments are one piece of a bigger financial puzzle that includes a mortgage, business income, or debt, this is the tool that fits.Its strength is simplicity. The format is deliberately plain: organized sections for each financial category, no prompts you did not ask for, no dated pages judging you for taking a month off. Compared with the Investment Planner, this notebook suits a quarterly or annual review cadence rather than a daily one — a perfectly valid style of tracking that many seasoned investors actually prefer. And unlike the My Investment Logbook, it gives you a predefined structure, so you are never staring at a blank page wondering how to organize your entries.The honest drawback is longevity. A limited page count means this is not a decade-long ledger — heavy users will fill it and need a replacement, which makes long-term trend tracking harder since your history ends up split across volumes. The manual entry requirement is also the price of admission here, and without any analytical structure, the insight you get depends entirely on the effort you put in. Still, for periodic whole-picture reviews, it is the most complete option we reviewed.
Pros:
- Only option in this lineup covering assets, liabilities, income, and net worth together
- Simple, organized format requires no learning curve
- Undated structure allows flexible tracking at your own cadence
- Works for both personal and business finances
Cons:
- Limited page count may not support long-term multi-year tracking
- No analytical prompts or guidance — value depends entirely on user discipline
- Manual entry only, with no automated calculations
Best for: Investors and households who want to track net worth — not just investments — through periodic structured reviews
Not ideal for: Daily trackers who want habit-building prompts, or investors who only care about portfolio performance in isolation
Bottom line: This option stands out for whole-balance-sheet visibility — it is the pick for investors whose net worth, not just their portfolio, is the number they care about.
“This option stands out for whole-balance-sheet visibility — it is the pick for investors whose net worth, not just their portfolio, is the number they care about.”
My Investment Logbook

Of the three, this is the purest record-keeping tool. The Investment Planner wants to shape your behavior; the Asset Management Record Notebook wants to map your whole balance sheet; this logbook simply wants to be the one place your investment and financial records live. That single-minded focus is its virtue. For investors who already have a routine and just need a durable home for entries, paying for structure you will ignore makes no sense.Its consolidated approach is the differentiator. Rather than splitting records across brokerage statements, spreadsheets, and scattered notes, everything sits in one volume — trades, dividends, contributions, and other financial records together. Compared with the Asset Management Record Notebook, it trades breadth for focus: you lose the liabilities and net worth sections, but investors tracking a securities portfolio only never needed those anyway.The limitation is the flip side of that freedom. With minimal imposed structure, the quality of your tracking depends entirely on the system you bring to it — two people using this logbook will produce completely different results. It offers no prompts, no cadence, and no analytical framework, so beginners who need guidance will get more from the dated Investment Planner. Sparse product details also mean you should expect a straightforward, no-frills format. For a confident investor with an established method, however, that blank-slate quality is exactly the appeal.
Pros:
- Keeps investment and financial records together in a single place
- No imposed structure — adapts to any tracking method or portfolio type
- Simple enough to start using immediately without setup
- Focused scope suits securities-only investors who skip extras
Cons:
- No built-in structure, prompts, or guidance — discipline is entirely on you
- Does not cover liabilities or net worth like the Asset Management Record Notebook
- Minimal published details on format and features
Best for: Experienced investors who already have a tracking routine and want one simple, flexible place for all investment and financial records
Not ideal for: Beginners who need structure and prompts, or investors wanting net worth or multi-asset planning features
Bottom line: Compared with similar options, this logbook wins on simplicity and freedom — the right pick if you need a records home, not a system that tells you what to do.
“Compared with similar options, this logbook wins on simplicity and freedom — the right pick if you need a records home, not a system that tells you what to do.”
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Key Differences
The single biggest gap between these two products is what they calculate. Empower shows you your balance and a headline return figure, which is enough to answer “how am I doing?” at a glance. Sharesight computes time-weighted and money-weighted returns, tracks every dividend, adjusts for currency movements, and lets you benchmark against indices. If you have ever deposited money mid-year and wondered whether your reported return is real or an artifact of cash flows, Sharesight answers that question and Empower generally does not.
The second major difference is scope. Empower is a whole-finances tool: checking accounts, credit cards, mortgages, real estate estimates, and retirement accounts all appear in one net worth picture. Sharesight deliberately ignores everything that is not an investment. That makes Empower the better single app for a household’s finances, and Sharesight the better single app for a serious portfolio — especially one spread across multiple brokers or countries, where Empower’s US-centric aggregation breaks down.
The third difference is the business model, and it shapes the experience. Empower is free because the company wants to convert you into a wealth management client; expect advisory outreach if your assets cross a threshold. Sharesight is free only up to ten holdings, and its paid plans are the product. Neither model is a problem for everyone, but you should know going in that Empower’s “free” has a sales funnel behind it, and Sharesight’s depth has a subscription behind it.
Detailed Comparison
Price and business model (Empower (formerly Personal Capital) wins — major)
Empower is entirely free for its tracking tools, with no holding limits or feature gates on the dashboard. The catch is that Empower monetizes through its paid wealth management service, so users with larger balances typically receive outreach from advisors. Sharesight uses a freemium model: a free plan limited to ten holdings is fine for a taste, but any real portfolio pushes you into a paid tier billed monthly or annually. For cost alone, Empower wins outright — but the comparison is only fair if Empower actually does what you need. Paying for Sharesight buys capability Empower does not sell at any price.
This is where the two products diverge most sharply. Empower reports your investment returns in a simplified form that can be distorted by deposits, withdrawals, and transfers between linked accounts — a lump-sum contribution can make a modest portfolio look like it had a spectacular month. Sharesight was built specifically to solve this, reporting both time-weighted returns (comparable to fund benchmarks) and money-weighted returns (reflecting your actual cash flows), along with dividend income tracking, franking or withholding tax details, and currency-adjusted returns. For anyone evaluating their strategy or comparing themselves to an index, this difference is not cosmetic — it changes the answer to the question you asked.
Asset and account coverage (Empower (formerly Personal Capital) wins — moderate)
Empower covers far more ground: bank accounts, credit cards, loans, mortgages, retirement accounts, manually added real estate and private assets, and cryptocurrency through integration. Sharesight covers listed stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, bonds, some crypto via connected exchanges, and alternative assets entered manually — but nothing banking-related. If your goal is a unified net worth view, Empower is clearly stronger. If your goal is investment record-keeping across brokers, Sharesight’s narrower but deeper coverage wins. The practical tradeoff: Empower sees everything shallowly; Sharesight sees investments deeply.
Empower offers essentially nothing here — it is a monitoring tool, not a record-keeping one. Sharesight produces capital gains reports, taxable income reports, and tax package documents for multiple jurisdictions including the US, UK, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand, with options for specific accounting methods where allowed. Investors with taxable accounts who want to hand their accountant clean numbers, or who need to track cost basis across broker transfers, get genuine value from this. It is one of the strongest reasons to pay for Sharesight, and a complete gap in Empower.
Automatic syncing reliability (Empower (formerly Personal Capital) wins — moderate)
Empower’s aggregation is mature for US institutions: link once, and balances refresh automatically with few issues for major banks and brokerages. Sharesight syncs trades automatically with a long list of brokers and via API connections, but many users — particularly those at unsupported brokers — will import trades via CSV or enter them manually, then maintain that discipline over time. Empower is more passive; Sharesight can be more work. That work buys accuracy and a permanent, broker-independent record, but if you want zero maintenance, Empower is the smoother experience.
Empower is built for the US market. Non-US brokerages, foreign-domiciled funds, and multi-currency portfolios are poorly served or unsupported. Sharesight supports dozens of exchanges globally, handles multiple base currencies, converts foreign holdings, and reports currency effects separately — making it one of the few serious options for expats and international investors. If your portfolio crosses borders, this criterion alone can decide the comparison.
Ease of use and setup (Empower (formerly Personal Capital) wins — moderate)
Empower takes minutes to set up: link accounts, and the dashboard populates itself. Its interface prioritizes clarity over depth. Sharesight requires more upfront effort — connecting brokers, importing historical trades, setting your base currency — and its interface is functional rather than polished. Neither is difficult, but Empower is meaningfully easier for a casual user, while Sharesight’s setup effort is a one-time cost for long-term analytical payoff.
Empower (formerly Personal Capital): Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Completely free with unlimited holdings and accounts
- Unified net worth view across banking, investments, debts, and property
- Excellent automatic syncing for US institutions
- Useful retirement planning and fee-checker tools
- Fast, low-effort setup and maintenance
Cons:
- Return figures can be misleading with mid-year cash flows
- No tax reports or dividend record-keeping for filings
- Wealth management upsell calls and emails for larger accounts
- Weak international broker and multi-currency support
- No benchmarking or money-weighted return analysis
Pros:
- Accurate TWR and MWR performance measurement
- Tax-ready reports for multiple countries
- Strong dividend and income tracking
- Multi-currency, multi-exchange support
- Permanent broker-independent portfolio record
Cons:
- Subscription cost for portfolios over ten holdings
- Investments only — no net worth or budgeting features
- Setup and ongoing maintenance can take real effort
- Interface is utilitarian compared to Empower’s polish
Who Should Choose What
Choose Empower (formerly Personal Capital) if:
- You want a free, low-effort dashboard showing net worth and approximate investment performance
- Your accounts are US-based and you value automatic syncing over analytical depth
- You mainly hold retirement accounts and index funds and do not file complex investment taxes
- You want budgeting and cash flow tools alongside portfolio tracking
Choose Sharesight if:
- You need accurate performance measurement accounting for deposits, withdrawals, and dividends
- You have taxable accounts and want capital gains and income reports for tax filing
- Your portfolio spans multiple brokers, countries, or currencies
- You benchmark yourself against indices and want to know your true return
Skip both if: You trade actively with real-time data needs or want institutional-grade research — a dedicated trading platform with built-in analytics serves you better than either tracker.
Value for Money
Empower is hard to beat on price because it costs nothing, and its free tools are genuinely good for monitoring. The hidden cost is the advisory sales funnel and the ceiling on analytical depth — you cannot pay Empower to produce a proper money-weighted return or a capital gains report.
Sharesight’s subscription only makes sense when its unique capabilities matter to you. If you have a taxable portfolio, multiple brokers, or international holdings, the paid plan replaces hours of spreadsheet work and reduces the risk of filing errors — that is easily worth the monthly fee. If you hold a handful of index funds in retirement accounts, Sharesight’s depth is wasted, and the free Empower dashboard answers every question you are actually asking. The value question is not “is Sharesight worth the money?” but “is accurate performance measurement and tax reporting worth the money?” For disciplined DIY investors, yes; for casual savers, no.
Final Verdict
These apps are not really competitors — they solve different problems, and the wrong choice comes from buying the wrong category. Choose Empower if you want a free, effortless, whole-finances dashboard and your needs stop at seeing balances, allocation, and a rough return figure. It is the right default for most US-based savers with retirement accounts and simple portfolios. Choose Sharesight if you are an active or analytical investor who needs true performance numbers, dividend records, multi-broker aggregation, or tax-ready reports — capabilities Empower does not offer at any price. The biggest deciding factor is whether you file taxes on your investments or measure yourself against benchmarks: if yes, Sharesight’s subscription pays for itself; if no, Empower’s free dashboard is all you need. Many serious investors use both — Empower for the household balance sheet, Sharesight for the portfolio — but if forced to pick one, most people should start with Empower and graduate to Sharesight only when its depth becomes necessary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Empower and Sharesight together?
Yes, and many investors do. They do not conflict: Empower handles net worth and cash flow across your whole financial life, while Sharesight tracks investment performance and tax records in depth. Using both covers each tool’s blind spots.
Why does Empower show a different return than Sharesight?
Usually because of cash flows. Empower’s return figures can be skewed by deposits and withdrawals, while Sharesight separates time-weighted and money-weighted returns to account for them. Sharesight’s numbers are generally the more accurate measure of your investing performance.
Only for testing or a very small portfolio. The ten-holding limit excludes even a moderately diversified ETF portfolio, and key reports are gated on paid tiers. Treat the free plan as a trial before subscribing.
Does Empower work outside the United States?
Poorly. Empower’s account aggregation and planning tools are built around US institutions, and non-US brokerages are largely unsupported. International investors should look at Sharesight or a regional alternative.
Is Empower really free, or will I get sales calls?
The tracking dashboard is free, but Empower earns money from wealth management. Users with assets above its advisory threshold should expect outreach from its advisory team. You can decline and keep using the free tools.
Fall Picks

Samsung 32-Inch Movingstyle Essential 4K UHD Smart Monitor with Rolling Stand
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
