TL;DR
Spartan Metals estimates it would cost $683 million to build an underground tungsten and molybdenum mine and processing plant at Victorio in New Mexico. Its preliminary economic assessment projects a 24-year operation, but the economics depend on metal prices and include inferred resources in the planned plant feed.
Spartan Metals estimates it would cost $683 million (C$978 million) to build an underground tungsten and molybdenum mine at its Victorio project in New Mexico, according to a preliminary economic assessment released Thursday. The proposed mine and processing plant are projected to operate for 24 years, with the study estimating an after-tax net present value of $2.14 billion at an 8% discount rate.
Get smart everyday buys delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The assessment also estimates a 31% internal rate of return under its base-case assumptions. It projects a further $2.03 billion in sustaining spending over the mine’s operating life, in addition to the initial construction estimate. The figures are study estimates, not a construction decision or a guarantee of future results.
Victorio would use block caving, an underground mining method that relies on gravity to break and move rock. The proposed plant would process tungsten concentrate into ammonium paratungstate, or APT, a feedstock used in cutting tools and other industrial products. The assessment forecasts annual production of about 4,100 tonnes of tungsten trioxide contained in APT and 8.65 million lb. of molybdenum in concentrate.
The study’s base case assumes tungsten trioxide at $1,350 per 10 kg and molybdenum at $20 per lb. At the lowest prices tested—$750 per 10 kg for tungsten trioxide and $15 per lb. for molybdenum—the projected after-tax NPV falls to $392 million and the internal rate of return to 14%. The assessment says inferred resources make up 39% of scheduled plant feed, a factor to account for as the project advances and its resource confidence is examined.
Spartan puts a $683M price tag on Victorio
Spartan Metals’ early study outlines a proposed tungsten and molybdenum mine in New Mexico. Its projected returns depend on metal prices, resource confidence and substantial future funding.
What the study proposes
Victorio is planned as an underground mine and processing plant in New Mexico.
The proposal uses block caving to break and move rock by gravity.
The plant would turn tungsten concentrate into ammonium paratungstate, used in cutting tools and other industrial products.
The study forecasts about 4,100 tonnes of tungsten trioxide in APT and 8.65 million lb. of molybdenum in concentrate each year.
Returns depend on prices
The assessment’s base case assumes tungsten trioxide at $1,350 per 10 kg and molybdenum at $20 per lb.
- After-tax NPV: $2.14 billion
- Internal rate of return: 31%
- After-tax NPV: $392 million
- Internal rate of return: 14%
What still needs work
The preliminary assessment is an early-stage study, not a construction decision.
Confirm scheduled feed
Inferred resources make up 39% of scheduled plant feed, so further work must examine resource confidence.
Test project requirements
Drilling, metallurgical testing, and water and tailings studies are recommended.
Secure substantial capital
No construction financing or decision is reported; the study also projects $2.03 billion in sustaining spending.
A Potential U.S. Tungsten Supply
Victorio could add a domestic source of tungsten and molybdenum if it moves through further studies, permitting, financing and construction. The U.S. Geological Survey says the United States last mined tungsten commercially in 2015. The proposed project is therefore relevant to industrial users and defense customers seeking supply beyond overseas processing networks.
China accounts for about 85% of global capacity to refine APT, according to S&P Global. China’s export controls are keeping supply tight, while some buyers are reluctant to accept elevated prices, Fastmarkets reported Thursday. That market backdrop may support interest in new supply, but Spartan’s own price sensitivity figures show that Victorio’s projected returns could change substantially with commodity prices.
The scale of the investment also matters. Spartan closed Thursday at C$0.26 per share in Toronto, unchanged on the day, giving the company a market value of about C$15.4 million ($10.7 million). Those figures underscore the gap between the company’s current valuation and the capital required by the study’s proposed development; the assessment does not say how construction funding would be secured.
Products Worth Considering

Dell 32 Plus 4K Monitor (S3225QS), 31.5-Inch VA, 120Hz, FreeSync Premium

Samsung 32-Inch ViewFinity S7 4K UHD IPS Monitor

Dell UltraSharp U4025QW 40-Inch Curved 5K2K WUHD LED Monitor
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Resource Estimate and Project Terms
An August resource estimate reported 76.7 million measured and indicated tonnes grading 0.1% tungsten trioxide and 0.09% molybdenum. The estimate lists contained amounts of 165.5 million lb. of tungsten trioxide and 147.9 million lb. of molybdenum. It also reports 92.4 million inferred tonnes grading 0.09% tungsten trioxide and 0.06% molybdenum, containing 187.6 million lb. and 130 million lb., respectively.
The resource categories carry different levels of confidence, and inferred material accounts for a substantial share of the feed scheduled in the assessment. Spartan has an option on the core Victorio claims from Donegan Resources. Under a March agreement, exercising the option requires cash payments, $14 million in exploration spending and delivery of a feasibility study by 2034.
Spartan is not the only company advancing a North American tungsten project. On Monday, Canada conditionally approved up to C$14 million in financing for Fireweed Metals to help move its Mactung project toward a construction decision. That development reflects broader efforts to advance regional supply, though it does not establish that either project will enter production.
“Both metals contribute to those economics, so continued price appreciation for either metal can make a meaningful difference to the underlying project economics.”
— Spartan CEO Brett Marsh
Key Feasibility Questions Remain
The preliminary assessment is an early-stage economic study, and it does not establish that Victorio can be built or operated on the projected schedule or budget. The company has not announced a construction decision or identified financing for the estimated $683 million initial cost and $2.03 billion in sustaining expenditures.
It is also not yet clear how much of the scheduled inferred resource can be confirmed through further drilling or how that work could affect mine design and economics. Water supply, tailings management and metallurgical performance require additional study. The assessment’s price cases further show that returns could be lower if tungsten or molybdenum prices fall below the assumptions used in its base case.
Drilling and Prefeasibility Work
Spartan plans to advance Victorio to a prefeasibility study. The assessment recommends $13.2 million in work, including drilling, metallurgical testing, and studies of water supply and tailings. Those investigations are intended to develop the technical and economic information needed for the next stage of project evaluation.
The option agreement sets a separate milestone: Spartan must complete a feasibility study by 2034 to exercise its option on the core claims, alongside the required cash payments and exploration spending. The company has not provided a construction timetable in the reported details. The next material update is likely to come as it carries out the recommended studies and reports whether the project’s resource, infrastructure needs and economics support further advancement.
Source: rss
Key Questions
What is Spartan proposing at Victorio?
Spartan is studying an underground tungsten and molybdenum mine in New Mexico, with a plant to make ammonium paratungstate feedstock from tungsten concentrate.
How much would the project cost?
The preliminary assessment estimates $683 million (C$978 million) for construction and a further $2.03 billion in sustaining spending over the projected 24-year operating life.
What returns does the study project?
Under its base-case price assumptions, the assessment estimates an after-tax NPV of $2.14 billion at an 8% discount rate and a 31% internal rate of return. At the lowest tested prices, it estimates an NPV of $392 million and a 14% return.
Has Spartan approved construction?
No construction decision is reported. Spartan plans further work toward prefeasibility, including drilling, metallurgical testing and studies of water supply and tailings.
What are the main outstanding risks?
Further work is needed on resource confidence, processing, water, tailings and project financing. The assessment also shows that projected returns are sensitive to tungsten and molybdenum prices.
Source: northernminer.com
